Guidelines for Creating & Facilitating a Workshop or Group Discussion on
The Golden Rule Across the World's Religions
A Do-It-Yourself Workshop
Compiled by John Milan & Paul McKenna
Permission to reproduce this document
in print or electronic form:We encourage the reproduction and use of this document for educational purposes.
The document may be abbreviated to fewer pages, but content may not be
substantially changed without permission of the copyright holder. For permission to
reproduce portions of the document for commercial use or for large-scale distribution, please request permission from Paul McKenna at tel. (416) 261-7135 or e-mail: interfaith@scarboromissions.ca. Print or electronic reproductions must include the following notice: Guidelines for a Golden Rule Workshop. Copyright © Paul McKenna 2002 Posters and Guidelines available from Conexus Multifaith Media
www.conexuspress.com / tel. 1-877-784-7779
To order the Golden Rule poster in the USA, call the toll-free number or
visit the web site below to place credit card orders. Price is US$8.95 (plus $4 S&H) for one poster, mailed first class in a protective tube. Quantity discounts available. www.conexuspress.com / tel. 1-877-784-7779 / Mail orders with payment to: CoNexus Multifaith Media
P.O. Box 39218 Solon, OH 44139 USA. To order in Canada, contact: Broughton's Religious Books & Gifts 416-690-4777 / sales@bbroughton.com
CN$9.95 plus tax and shipping
If we take the world’s enduring religions at
their best, we discover the distilled wisdom of the human race. -Huston Smith
Thirteen Sacred Texts
Native Spirituality
We are as much alive as we keep the earth alive. Chief Dan George
Baha'i
Lay not on any soul a load that you would not wish to be laid
upon you,
and desire not for anyone the things you would not desire for yourself.
Baha'u'llah, Gleanings
Buddhism
Treat not others in ways that you yourself would find hurtful.
The Buddha, Udana-Varga 5.1
Christianity
In everything, do to others as you would have them do to you;
for this is the law and the prophets.
Jesus, the Christ, Matthew 7:12
Confucianism
One word which sums up the basis of all good conduct....loving-kindness.
Do not do to others what you do not want done to yourself.
Confucius, Analects
15.23
Hinduism
This is the sum of duty: do not do to others what would cause pain
if done to you.
Mahabharata 5:1517
Islam
Not one of you truly believes until you wish for others what you wish for yourself.
The Prophet Muhammad, 13th of the 40 Hadiths of Nawawi
Jainism
One should treat all creatures in the world as one would like to be
treated.
Mahavira, Sutrakritanga
Judaism
What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbour. This is the
whole Torah; all the rest is commentary. Go and learn it.
Hillel, Talmud, Shabbath 31a
Sikhism
I am a stranger to no one; and no one is a stranger to me. Indeed, I am a friend to all.
Guru Granth Sahib, pg. 1299
Taoism
Regard your neighbour's gain as your own gain and your neighbour's loss
as your own loss.
Lao Tzu, T'ai Shang Kan Ying P'ien, 213-218
Unitarianism
We affirm and promote respect for the interdependent web of all existence
of which we are a part.
Unitarian principle
Zoroastrianism
Do not do unto others whatever is injurious to yourself.
Shayast-na-Shayast 13.29
Why Create a Golden Rule Workshop?
At a dramatic pace, more and more regions of the world are becoming
environments of multi-culture and multi-faith. This trend is having a profound effect upon
public education, religious education, ethical education and education for social justice.
Growing numbers of educators are discovering that religious and ethical education can no
longer be conducted from the perspective of only one religion or culture. Indeed,
religious educators of the future will call upon the wisdom and teachings of numerous
religious and humanist traditions.
These guidelines are meant to be a small step toward this now-and-future
direction. In this proposed workshop or group discussion experience, participants will be
invited to reflect from the perspective of a universal moral principle – the Golden
Rule – in its many and various expressions across the world’s religions.
People are often surprised and pleased to discover versions of the Golden Rule in
so many religions and secular philosophies. In this workshop, you will be working with 13
expressions of the Golden Rule. It should be noted, however, that researchers have
discovered versions in numerous other religious traditions. Because the Golden Rule
crosses so many traditions and philosophies, it possesses tremendous moral authority and
indicates a profound human unity.
This workshop has been tested in a number of environments and has consistently
generated great enthusiasm, reflection and discussion. Any group or individual who decides
to sponsor it can expect rich and varied responses. This workshop also aims to provide
tools for reflection and action in terms of the great ethical and social issues of our
time.
Preparation
This is a do-it-yourself workshop. The guidelines that follow are meant
to equip an individual or group to sponsor, create and facilitate a Golden Rule Across
the World’s Religions workshop. Any group interested in sponsoring this workshop
would benefit by first forming a planning group.
The planning group can review the range of choices and options outlined in these
detailed guidelines. Again, these are just guidelines. The planning group may want to
change, adapt or shorten the proposed program. For example, the guidelines
contain suggested time frames for various sections of the program. But these are just
suggestions and can be varied.
You will note that there is a good deal of time allotted for the participants to
do private reflection during the workshop. The developers of these guidelines have learned
that the process of individual reflection deepens the experience of the participants.
Again, the planning group may want to vary this component of the process.
The target audience for this workshop is both adults and youth. It is hoped, for
example, that this program will be utilized in adult and youth education programs in
mosques, temples, gurdwaras, synagogues, churches, meditation centres, spiritual
fellowships, etc. In fact, on a given day, an adult workshop and a children’s
workshop can be offered simultaneously in the same locale.
Please note that the constituency for this workshop can be a single-faith or a
multi-faith audience. This workshop is also relevant to audiences that do not define
themselves as "religious" or "spiritual" because the workshop content
deals largely with ethics.
What you will need for the
workshop
- Paper and pens for journaling
- Flip chart for use in Steps 4, 5 & 9 below
- Questions selected for use in Step 4
- Preparatory questions for small group discussion (Step 5)
- Questions about the learnings and experience of the workshop participants (Step 9)
- Evaluation forms (Step 11)
- A copy of the 13 Sacred Writings for each workshop participant; these writings can
be downloaded from the opening section of this document
- Golden Rule poster featuring a symbolic and written depiction of the Golden Rule in
13 religions. The poster is not necessary for the workshop but is a helpful visual aid. To order the poster or to get a visual sense of the poster, see pages 1-2 of this
document.
Workshop outline in 13
steps:
Here follows a framework of 13 steps to guide the planning group in developing and
presenting its workshop. As an aid to the planning group and facilitator, these steps are
listed in both short form and long form:
Step 1 - Welcome & Introduction
Step 2 - Distribution of Sacred Texts
Step 3 - Silent Meditation
Step 4 - Individual Reflection
Step 5 - Preparation for Group Discussion
Step 6 - Group Discussion
Step 7 - Plenary Discussion
Step 8 - Appropriation of Learnings
Step 9 - Sharing of Learnings
Step 10 - Facilitator’s Comments
Step 11 - Evaluation
Step 12 - Next Steps
Step 13 - Closing Prayer/Meditation
Step 1 - Welcome & Introduction
Facilitator welcomes the participants and outlines the program and process of
the workshop. If the group is not too large, participants can be asked to introduce
themselves and comment on what attracted them to this workshop.
Step 2 - Distribution of Sacred Texts
Facilitator provides each participant with a sheet containing the 13 written
versions of the Golden Rule (this information can be downloaded from the opening section
of this document).
Step 3 - Silent Meditation
All participants are invited to spend a few minutes in silence, reading and
reflecting on the 13 Sacred Writings. Facilitator can explain that the practice of
reflection and meditation on sacred texts in silence is common to many religious
traditions.
Suggested time frame: 5 to 7 minutes
Step 4 - Individual Reflection
Workshop participants continue their private and silent reflection in response
to two or three questions provided them by the facilitator. The questions can also be
listed on a flipchart. Participants may wish to journal their reflections. Suggested
time frame: 7 to 12 minutes.
Prior to the workshop, the planning group prepares two or three questions
appropriate to its audience, to stimulate private reflection and group discussion. The
planners may want to provide just one question. On the other hand, they may choose more
than two or three questions, perhaps as many as five or six. By increasing the number of
questions, the planners are able to provide more rich material for reflection. However,
more questions may lead to overstimulation of the individual reflections and of the
subsequent small group process and plenary. So again, this is a decision for the planning
group.
If the constituency is a specialized group (e.g. hospital chaplains, teachers,
teenagers, social justice activists), questions can be geared to its specific needs. If
the constituency wants to deal with a specific issue (e.g. ecology, social justice,
violence, compassion), the questions can likewise be oriented to such.
Numerous sample questions are listed below, in three categories:
a) the message of the Golden Rule,
b) the message of the Golden Rule for you,
c) the Golden Rule and its implications for society
The planning group may use the following space to write its chosen questions:
Question 1
Question 2
Question 3
Step 5 - Preparation for Group Discussion
Each participant prepares for the small group discussion by quietly reflecting for
a few minutes on the fruit of her/his meditation in Step 4. To stimulate this reflection,
the facilitator provides each participant with the following questions (please note that
the purpose here is not to repeat or rehash the reflection of the previous step but to
prepare the participant for the small group discussion.):
- What new insights, thoughts, questions or good ideas do I have
as a result of my reflection on these Sacred Writings?
- What feelings surfaced in me as I perused these writings?
- What would I like to share with my small group?
- How will I share, briefly, but completely?
Journaling is optional. Suggested time frame: 3 to 5 minutes
Step 6 - Group Discussion
Participants break into discussion groups (4 to 7 persons per group). The planning
group may want to designate group leaders in advance. Suggested time frame: 20 to 45
minutes
Step 7 - Plenary Discussion
Facilitator convenes all participants into a plenary. Participants are invited to
give feedback by way of either group reports or spontaneous comments. It may be helpful to
to record key elements of the feedback content on flip chart paper. Following the
feedback, the facilitator stimulates discussion within the plenary. Suggested time
frame: 20 to 45 minutes
Step 8 - Appropriation of Learnings
Facilitator asks each participant to take some quiet time (4 to 7 minutes)
to reflect on her/his experience of and learnings from the program (journalling is
optional). Some of the following questions can be used to stimulate private reflection:
- What have I learned during this workshop?
- What new insights have surfaced for me?
- What is coming clearer to me, now?
- As a result of this workshop, I feel moved to......
Step 9 - Sharing of Learnings
Facilitator asks some or all of the participants to share one learning from
the program. These could be recorded on a flip chart. Alternatively, these learnings could
also be shared in groups of two.
Step 10 - Facilitator’s Comments
At this point, the facilitator may want to share some specific or general
comments on the notion of The Golden Rule Across The World’s Religions. The
facilitator may also want to comment on the feedback reports and plenary discussion and
make a summary statement.
Step 11 - Evaluation
Participants are invited to evaluate the workshop process. The planning group
may design evaluation forms in advance.
Step 12 - Next Steps
The facilitator and participants take some time to determine if they want to
do any follow-up to this workshop. For example, would it be helpful to organize additional
workshops? Or to integrate the themes and learnings of this workshop into other projects
that the participants or planning group are involved in?
Step 13 - Closing Prayer/Meditation
Workshop could close with an experience of
prayer/meditation/liturgy/song/poetry/chant related to the theme. One option is to have
people meditate quietly for a minute on the Sacred Writings. Following this, 13
individuals can recite, one-by-one, in a rotation fashion, the individual sacred texts.
Sample questions for use in step 4
In Step 4, the participants are invited to do individual reflection in
response to two or three questions provided by the facilitator. The planning group is
responsible for creating these reflection questions. To aid the planning group in this
task, numerous sample questions are listed below, divided into three categories:
- a) the message of the Golden Rule
- b) the message of the Golden Rule for you
- c) the Golden Rule and its implications for society
a) The message of the Golden Rule
- What is the message of the Golden Rule?
- A similar moral principle is expressed in the Sacred Writings of these 13 religious
traditions? What conclusions can you draw from this fact?
- Can you see differences and similarities among the 13 Sacred Texts? What are they?
- Virtually all religions and spiritual traditions emphasize love and compassion for
neighbour. How, in your opinion, does this universal teaching relate to the message of
these Sacred Writings?
- Are you aware of the title or message of a TV program, book or popular song which
expresses the same idea as the Golden Rule? Explain.
b) The message of the Golden Rule for you
- Which expression of the Golden Rule do you like the best? Why?
- How would you express the Golden Rule in your own words?
- Think of one occasion when someone treated you in the spirit of the Golden Rule.
When was that? Who was involved? What was that like for you? How did you feel? How do you
understand the behaviour of the other party involved in this incident?
- Think of one occasion when you treated someone in the spirit of the Golden Rule.
When was that? Who was involved? What was that like for you? How did you feel? What is
your sense of the other party’s reaction to your behaviour in that situation?
- Think of one occasion when someone treated you in a manner that violated the Golden
Rule. When was that? Who was involved? What was that like for you? How did you feel? How
do you understand the behaviour of the other party involved in that incident?
- Think of one occasion when you treated someone in a manner that violated the Golden
Rule. When was that? Who was involved? What was that like for you? How did you feel? What
is your sense of the other party’s reaction to your behaviour in that situation?
- Did anything in these Sacred Writings get you thinking? Identify it. Did it
interest, stimulate or energize you? Or, did it irritate, challenge or bewilder you? Why?
- What surprises you about these Sacred Texts? Why? What challenges you? Puzzles you?
Why?
- What insights or good ideas come to you as you reflect on these Sacred Writings?
- What doubts or questions are raised for you as you ponder these Sacred Texts?
- Has anything in these Sacred Writings so caught your interest that you might want
to investigate it more fully? What? Why?
- Is there something you can name within your workplace (or school, family, city,
etc.) that promotes or prevents the practice of the Golden Rule?
- If you were to live by the Golden Rule each and every day, what would be different
in your life? Your personal life? Family life? Work Life? Community Life? etc.
- Can the Golden Rule be realistically applied in day-to-day life? Why or why not?
Can you think of a good example from your experience? Describe it.
- Do you belong to one of the 13 spiritual traditions represented in this collection
of Sacred Texts? If so, how do you understand your tradition’s version of the Golden
Rule in light of the other 12? And how do you understand the other 12 in light of yours?
- Some people argue that the Golden Rule contains a profound call to solidarity with
neighbor, a profound call to empathy and compassion for all. As you read and reflect on
these 13 Sacred Writings, do you believe it is really possible for you "to get inside
another person’s skin", "to walk in your neighbor’s moccasins",
to feel the joy and pain of another person? Explain.
- In light of these13 Sacred Writings, what is your reaction to the following
statement: "my search for happiness, meaning and freedom has everything to do with my
commitment to bringing about your happiness, your meaning and your freedom"?
- Do you see ways in which these Sacred Texts could be helpful to you in terms of
prayer and meditation? Explain.
- As a result of my reflections on these Sacred Writings, I feel moved to......
c) The Golden Rule’s implications for society
- What could things be like if everyone behaved according to the Golden Rule? Why is
it that sometimes we don’t behave according to the Golden Rule?
- Do you think that people generally live by the Golden Rule? Why? Why not? If not,
what Rule do you think many people do live by?
- How do people usually treat each other at work (school, home, etc.)? Why is that
so? How might the Golden Rule make a difference?
- To what current issue in your city or country might the Golden Rule offer a
solution? How so?
- Do you think that these Sacred Writings could be helpful in promoting conversation,
communication and harmony within a family? Why or why not? Do you think that these
writings could be helpful in promoting such communication among families, including
families of various faiths? Why or why not?
- Select a social, political, economic or religious issue that interests you. How
might these Sacred Writings contribute to your thinking about or acting on this issue?
- How, in your opinion, do these Sacred Texts challenge us in terms of our
relationships with people who are hurting e.g. the hospitalized, the imprisoned, the
abused, the homeless, refugees etc.?
- Do you think that these Sacred Writings could be helpful in bringing about equality
between women and men? Why or why not?
- Do you think that these Sacred Texts could be helpful in healing a societal disease
known as racism? Why or why not?
- Do you think that these Sacred Writings could be helpful in promoting a deeper
appreciation of racial, cultural and religious diversity? Why or why not?
- From the domestic to the international level, there appears to be a growing
reliance on violence to resolve conflict? Do you think that these Sacred Writings could be
helpful in promoting a non-violent approach to conflict-resolution? Why or why not?
- For all beings on this planet, ecological destruction is a threatening development.
Do you think that these Sacred Texts could be helpful in efforts to protect and heal
Mother Earth? Why or why not?
- Do you think that these Sacred Texts could be helpful in efforts to promote social
and economic justice for all? Why or Why not?
- Do you see any connection between the message of these 13 Sacred Writings and the
UN’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights? Why or Why not?
- Across the planet, thousands of people including educators, humanitarians and
religious people are working to develop a Global Ethic (www.global-ethic.org).
This effort to develop a universal ethic, which calls upon the wisdom of the world’s
many religions, considers the Golden Rule to be a key reference point. Here, the Golden
Rule is not just a moral ideal for relationships between people but also for relationships
among nations, cultures, races and religions. Do you think that the development of a Global
Ethic is important? Why or why not?
If yes, do you think that the Golden Rule could make an important contribution to this
universal ethic? Why or why not?
- Do you think that these Sacred Texts could be helpful in efforts to promote
interfaith dialogue? Why or why not?
- Where do you think there is a special need for these Sacred Writings today? Why?
Other helpful hints for the planning group
1) Ideal number of participants for workshop: This workshop could be
conducted with a handful of participants or with as many as 200 participants. Larger
audience sizes will necessitate more sophisticated planning and more skills on the part of
the facilitator.
2) Estimated time frame of workshop: A trimmed-down version of this
workshop could be conducted in an hour. On the other hand, the workshop could be a
day-long event.
3) An extra step: In Step 6 of the workshop outline, participants are
invited to break into small groups (4 to 7 people). An alternative to this is to have
participants work in groups of two.
4) Using the arts: To enrich the workshop, the planners may want to
integrate music, art, dance, culture, etc. into the program.
5) Breaks: The number, positioning and duration of breaks are left to the
discretion of the planning group and facilitator.
*************************************
There are realms of gold hidden deep
- Hindu proverb
************************************
"We are interdependent. Each of us depends on the well-being of the
whole, and so we have respect for the community of living beings. . . . We must treat
others as we wish others to treat us. We make a commitment to respect life and dignity,
individuality and diversity, so that every person is treated humanely, without
exception."
--from Towards a Global Ethic - An Initial Declaration,
signed by 300 representatives of the world’s religions at the 1993 Parliament of the
World’s Religions in Chicago
Resources
There are now literally thousands of "golden
rule" websites on the Internet. Simply search under the category of "golden
rule". Please note that some of these sites are merely companies which happen to
have the words "golden rule" in their title description. Here a few key sites:
Golden Rule Solutions - www.goldenrulesolutions.com
Committee for the Golden Rule - http://patriot.net/~bmcgin/golden.html
The Golden Rule - http://www.jcu.edu/philosophy/gensler/goldrule.htm
Teaching Values - www.teachingvalues.com
Here are three important books in this field:
The Golden Rule, Jeffrey Wattles, Oxford Press, 1996
Formal Ethics, Harry Gensler, Routledge, 1996
Ethics - A Contemporary Introduction, Harry Gensler, Routledge, 1998
**************************
The guidelines in this document were developed by John Milan and Paul
McKenna in Toronto, Canada. John has a background in group process, social justice and
spiritual direction. Paul works as associate interfaith co-ordinator at Scarboro Missions
in Toronto. But the quality of this document is largely the result of consultation with a
number of individuals, all of whom are committed to inter-racial, intercultural and
inter-religious cooperation. These persons are: Joel Beversluis, Ellen Campbell, Gerald
Filson, Fr. J.P. Horrigan S.J., Leslie Mezei, Tony Muhitch, Paul Nazareth, Patricia
O’Connor, Fr. Ray O’Toole SFM, Charles Purdy, Joseph Romain, Ted Slavin, Kathy
VanLoon, Beverly Vantomne, Sharon Willan, Larry Windland.
If you would like to contact the designers of these guidelines with suggestions for
improvements of this document or for any other purpose, contact Paul McKenna at tel. (416)
261-7135 or e-mail interfaith@scarboromissions.ca
*********************************
To order The Golden Rule Posters, A
Call to Our Guiding Institutions with the Declaration Toward A Global Ethic,
Multifaith Calendars, a Festivals Poster, and other multifaith materials, contact:
Conexus Multifaith Media
P.O. Box 39218
Solon, OH 44139 USA
www.conexuspress.com / tel toll-free:
1-877-784-7779
Centered in Your presence, dear God, I let go of every concern and my soul awakens to new blessings of Your love and grace.